December 11, 2008
Posted: 919 GMT

BEIJING, China – Yesterday was just not a good day to be a journalist in China.  Producers at the CNN International weather show wanted to do stories on how transportation is affected by bad weather. They asked the Beijing bureau to find this out: what is China doing to ensure safe and unimpeded train travel?

After all, China had a bad experience last spring, when heavy, protracted snowstorms paralyzed the rail system in south China and stranded millions of anxious travelers. We thought it would be good to highlight China's efforts to learn from that experience. The Chinese must be quite eager to tell this story, we thought.

Not really. By phone and fax, our intrepid news assistant Yang Yuli, placed a request to the Ministry of Railways (MOR) for an interview and news shoot. Ideally, she said politely, we wished to do that the following week. It's a good opportunity for China to share its experience and knowledge, she said as she appealed to MOR's office of international affairs.

The ministry is very, very busy lately, she was cautioned, but they would consider our request.

Five days later, Yuli phoned to follow up. MOR is simply too busy and the lead time is just too short. Could they give us a definite "yes" or "no"? We were told to keep waiting.

Meantime, same day, another story idea came up. How about doing a story on Wu Yulu, a farmer in suburban Beijing who is said to have built robots in his spare time? Wu did not finish high school but he has reportedly built 26 robots from scrap metal and bearings. Among them, a human-shaped automaton that pulls a rickshaw for six hours on a single electric charge.

Wu may not get a Nobel Prize nomination for his efforts, but I thought his story was so colorful it merited a closer look.  In some ways, I thought, his story showed Chinese ingenuity and resourcefulness.

Beijing bureau producer Judy Kwon tracked down Wu's home phone. His wife answered. Wu is too busy, she said, and Judy should talk to her, instead. Judy explained why we wished to interview Wu and what kind of story we wished to do, but Wu's wife interrupted to ask if there would be any "laogong fee" (service fee). No, Judy explained, as a company policy we do not pay nor accept payment for interviews or stories. No deal then, Wu's wife said curtly. Four members of the family rely on Wu so they need financial support. Judy kept pushing, saying we don't pay, but this could be a good opportunity for Wu to get international exposure. Does that mean no payment, no interview?

Long pause ...

This time, we got a quick and firm answer.

No-go on Wu Yulu.  No-go on the train story.

Posted by: , ,
Filed under: China • Weather


Share this on:
tom wittmann   December 11th, 2008 2310 GMT

Dear Jaime

Are you new in China ??

Of course, the MOR cannot grant you such interview as they had to admit the disastrous security level of the raiways (and many other
services). The main problem in spring was not only a Railway issue,
but the supply of electricity, due to High Voltage Power lines with
low quality insulators, which provoke short circuits in the lines under
heavy rain or snow. Corrupt manufacturers and suppliers delivered such to yhe also corrupt tElectricty utilities !!

And the "farmer" who made such phantastic break trroughs ??

You (or CNN) were lucky that you refused to pay, as this would have
been the last what you would have heard of this.

If you wish some other info regarding Chinese procedures, please
ciontact me !!

TOM

chan   December 11th, 2008 2336 GMT

good questions, keep trying.

thanks

Percival Jones   December 12th, 2008 121 GMT

The MOR would not want to re-visit the past, unless they can show progress. They have a certain way of marketing themselves. With regards to the robot story, many in China, and Taiwan for that matter, are very capable, but they have know idea how to market their product. That may be where your story lies, not with farmer Wu and his parasitic family members, but with they idea of "marketing" in greater China.

Jeff Fu   December 12th, 2008 134 GMT

Wu's wife is an excellent example of the real comtemperory chinese. Wu might make himself a celebrity in the village by building robots, but he as everyother farmer in China still needs to feed his family. In a society flooded with materialism, the need for innovation will be quenched by the need for better housing or even bread if there is no return.

This is a really sad reality in china, everyone is so busy making as much money as he can. And for those people like Wu, who devote their time other than making money but making value and dream, there is simply no appreciation coming from the government or society.

Vivian   December 12th, 2008 136 GMT

Thank you for your story on a typical day in China. I am very suprised from reading your second story about the interview with Wu Yulu. I actually heard about him while I was in China. The Beijing Local Channel (BTV2) did an interview on him not too long ago. I am just suprised that how money driven they were to you, but they didn't not rebuff the BTV. I guess the communist government still is what the people fears for.

I am sure that you must be very dissappointed about not able to get them done, but I hope you learnt about China from a hard way. This is China, no morality, no humility, no sense of appreciation or an idel of sharing. The only force that drives the people in their daily lives including the poors, the riches, and the government officials, is the money from the devil.

Brian in Taipei   December 12th, 2008 220 GMT

What you experienced is not uncommon at all. In point of fact, it's the norm there, sad to say.

Sam   December 12th, 2008 228 GMT

To Tom,

Are you sure you really know the real reason of the problem in Spring 08.

You only got right on the first point. Yes, it is mainly a electricity problem rather than the railway issues. but it is not due to High Voltage Power lines with low quality insulators. It is basically because of the unprecedented cold weather in the southern part of China, which cause the Power lines frozen with heavy ice and eventually crashed the Power Towers causing power disruption in large area. As the power supply down, the railway transport was down.

L.HAN   December 12th, 2008 251 GMT

huge country always has some problems especially in China, largest population on the planet, transportation always encounter problems, but I hope and believe there are improving everyday.

MW   December 12th, 2008 407 GMT

To Sam

then there should be nothing to scare of when talking to the press, after all, doesn't china want to tell the whole world that it is making progress everyday, scientifically and ethically, and a country that the whole world can count on??

Wu's robots?? yeah right, tell us more about it.

Alan   December 12th, 2008 448 GMT

I think the reason why your interview request is rejected is because MOR and the farmer's family don't like to be interviewed by CNN. Not just because they are busy. Everyone has the right to refuse such an interview, they are just refusing in their own way.

Xia Kun   December 12th, 2008 450 GMT

Chinese people have their own way of life.. why do cnn try to
judge them with cnn norms.. or see them through their glasses.
If one wants to intervew or write a story there, then first must send
someone who can understand them and understand the way they
do things.
China, people and goverment, are no different from other nations,
but the way they live and think is different, just like thier language.

guys!
Think out of the box.

AnonymousMan   December 12th, 2008 935 GMT

China, land of opaqueness. Even here in Hong Kong, which nominally has an "open" government, the number of brick walls you can encounter with anything government related is frightening.

diana   December 12th, 2008 1430 GMT

When I was in Beijing, I could easily book a train ticket from New York to Boston half a month ahead via the US Amtrak online booking system sitting in the comfort of my sofa, but have to wait in long queue outside the Beijing train station in freezing winter, keeping my fingers crossed that there would be one ticket left for me. While I always had bad experience purchasing train ticket in China, I tried to understand in a way that this phenomenon is simply due to the huge demand for tickets especially in holiday seasons and the limited transportation capacity, a basic economics problem of supply in short of demand. Given the large population and the Chinese tradition of going back home to unite with the family in new year and spring festival, the problem will recur every year if the total transportation capacity could not enlarge to meet the demand.

bob bierman   December 12th, 2008 1956 GMT

this story is priceless! so many "technical difficulties" - even on the smallest things ....

perhaps you need to codify these into a "30 years of covering china" book!

John   December 12th, 2008 2000 GMT

Maybe the MOR was really busy. Maybe they did not trust that CNN could give them an objective and fair coverage. Or maybe they were not good at PR.

As to Mrs. Wu, she is a farmer's wife and probably did not know who CNN was and did not know how to take advance of the free marketing. She has a lot to learn from Dalai Lama.

threemeals   December 14th, 2008 220 GMT

What?! Oh, no! Jamie FlorCruz, did they make your life miserable?

I remember, about ten years ago, Donald Sutherland, the actor of the biographic movie, Bethune complained about the hardship in China playing the hero. Sr. Sutherland complained he had no proper toilet to defecate. How about yours? Tell us about the toilet story next time.

Sutherland is a movie star, so he complained. Is CNN going to give you a promotion if you complain like this? This is the time of economic crisis and recession, not everybody has work. So be careful with your complaints. Is this a good time to ask for more?

Get out there quickly. When natural disasters happen (like the earth quake), you want to survive, don't you? You ain't a star anyway, so why don't you come back to ride the sub?

threemeals   December 15th, 2008 2002 GMT

AnonymousMan,

Have you ever thought about how many Bernard Madoff are out there? In a land of transparent, you can only find one or two once awhile. Your grandpas' saving were stolen by these transparent guys. Go and count your account and see how much has been stolen! Or they are transparent, you are blind (or no brain).

You are not transparent yourself as the AnonymousMan, aren't you? And blind (lost your grandpa's saving to Bernard Madoff). Or you are trying to duck as Bernard Madoff?

threemeals   December 17th, 2008 152 GMT

Alan, I agree. They probably all would refuse because they have really got to know CNN. These people had it – unbiased prejudential reporting by now!

If they all refuse, Jamie FlorCruz can change his job. How about try something on Wall Street and reporting the stolen 50 billion dollars by Bernard Madoff. It is his Papas' and Mamas' retirement funds were stolen after all. These are poor elderly people's life savings. These old people can never make it back because not much time left. Jamie FlorCurz, the younger man, should go and save his Papa and Mama's savings! Or he may protect his own not be stolen in the future at least. Anyho, complaints about Wu does not help, doesn't it?

threemeals   December 17th, 2008 207 GMT

Vivian, lets face it – both Bernard Madoff and you are chasing the money (dollars) printed by the Fed, so is Wu. How do you found out that you have morality and he does not?

threemeals   December 17th, 2008 457 GMT

It's well known that China is a primitive society and the people cannot hide their greed, a newly learned desire. Those who are civilized like Bernard Madoff, Vivian, et al. always are morally superior, even after stealing estimated 50 billions dollars. For these people, the greed is not learned but just an instinct, right, Vivian? So your greed is not a moral issue. I like that!

But do you realized what Bernard Madoff stole also includes your Papa and Mama's life saving? Are you feeling alright, Vivian? Your family's money is missing. What the heck! It's all from the devil anyho, right, Vivian? China makes it, and you and Madoff steal it. Heh, heh, the devil feels alright.

threemeals   January 9th, 2009 1948 GMT

Things become transparent when the money is all gone. Vivian, what's your make of this one?

According to CNN:

She used to lunch at the Four Seasons. Now the best-selling author jokes that she's inviting friends to Taco Bell. Call it gallows humor, but Alexandra Penney has just lost her life's savings. She invested every penny with accused Ponzi-schemer Bernard Madoff.

threemeals   February 2nd, 2009 1921 GMT

Fox News:

"HARRISONVILLE, Mo. — The sister of a girl who was allegedly molested and impregnated four times by their father says she wanted to end her pain.

"My dad was doing all this crazy stuff," the 18-year-old told The Associated Press in an interview Thursday. "I got fed up with it until I finally ran my mouth. ... I couldn't see my sister suffer anymore. That's why I wanted ..."

Vivian, humans sometimes do things that animals don't. And animals don't talk nonsense.

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CNNInTheField on TwitterGet In The Field updates when they appear online via the Web, SMS, or instant messages.

Follow CNNInTheField

From our Partners
Categories
Powered by WordPress.com VIP