Edition: U.S. | Arabic | Set Pref
December 4, 2008
Posted: 2003 GMT
Looking out of the French windows to the back garden, it is a heart-warming sight. A two-year-old boy is squealing with delight as he bats a balloon around with his nanny. Then he furrows his brow in intense concentration as he draws her a picture.
Sandra Samuel and Moshe Holtzberg were the only ones to survive a siege on Mumbai's Chabad House last week.
Sandra Samuel and Moshe Holtzberg were the only ones to survive a siege on Mumbai's Chabad House last week.

It is hard to believe this little boy lost his mother and father in the attack on Mumbai’s Chabad House Jewish Center last week — his parents, the center’s directors Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his wife, Rivka, were among six people who perished — but the hope is that he is too young to remember too much.

We keep out of sight. Strangers, understandably, upset him.

Only our Israeli cameraman Avi is allowed up close. He has a baby almost the same age as Moshe, and after handing him back his errant balloon he becomes accepted in the circle of trust.

His nanny Sandra Samuel is only told of our interview 10 minutes before we arrive. Those protecting her didn’t want her worrying about it on top of the incredibly traumatic experience she has already been through. Watch more on Moshe’s escape

As she walks into the room, I am struck by how petite and how poised she is.

Within minutes you feel this woman’s inner strength and her utter devotion to the two-year-old whose life she saved.

During the height of the attacks that killed 179 people across Mumbai, Samuel spent 12 hours locked in a storeroom after being shot at by one of the gunmen. As the siege continued, she left this relative safe place, not knowing where the gunmen were, the second she heard the baby calling her name.

She denies she is brave, saying simply this baby is very precious to her and no one thinks of dying with a small precious baby in your arms.

She even feels guilt that she didn’t also save the rabbi and his wife, both shot by the gunmen. When I ask her how she is coping, she laughs at the thought of worrying about herself or even talking about herself saying simply: “Baby’s there, Sandra’s there, that’s it.”

One thing that clearly disturbs her is that she knows Moshe was asleep on the fifth floor of the Jewish Center when the gunmen entered. She found him on the second floor and with a perfect handprint mark on his back. The thought of a gunman carrying him down the stairs and hitting him is too much for her.

We keep the interview fairly short — Moshe becomes inconsolable if he’s parted from Sandra for too long. She is the one constant in his young life at the moment that he can cling to, and he is not letting go.

The second he is back in her arms, he smiles.

Moshe is surrounded by a lot of people who adore him, he will never want for help, financial or emotional. But the worry is he will never know his parents. Those close to him are torn between hoping he remembers nothing of the attack but hoping he will remember something of his parents who adored him.

For the first few days, he constantly cried for his mother and was inconsolable. He cries less now he has the distraction of a garden filled with toys, but Sandra knows the difficult and heart-breaking questions are still to come.

A family is destroyed; a little boy orphaned. The utter waste is heart-breaking.

Watch my interview with Sandra Samuel

Posted by: ,
Filed under: General • India


Share this on:
MATT MATHEWS   December 4th, 2008 2319 GMT

THE LOVE OF THE NANNY AND THE COURAGE AND THE UNSELFISH HEROIC ACT TO SAVE THE BABY DURING THE TURMOIL IS INCREDIBLE. THIS LADY SHOULD BE HONOURED. THIS PICTURE SHOULD BE THE PICTURE OF THE YEAR AND SHOULD BE SHOWN ALL OVER THE WORLD.

Gerry   December 5th, 2008 204 GMT

I only cry when I read about this. My wife and I have a young son too. Sandra is right, if my son were in danger, I would not even think about it.

It is love that holds the world together, and it will be love that somehow puts the pieces back together again, and fills in the gaps of all the missing.

Philip Rose   December 5th, 2008 211 GMT

What a wonderful story, especially after hearing Pastor Rick Warren talk about the purpose of Christmas and the world needing to come together. And how fascinating and provocative that this child of alien parents, whose name is translated as Moses, would be rescued from death by a compassionate indiginous woman who heard his cry. Perhaps there is yet hope for us in this troubled world.

Rev. Philip Rose

Sara B.   December 5th, 2008 213 GMT

Thank you for bringing us an image of Moshe smiling. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve looked at my two-year-old son in the past several days and felt love mixed with grief for this huge loss — both to two children, a family, and an entire community.

George   December 5th, 2008 228 GMT

I am an American of Indian origin and I am proud to be from the same country that Sandra Sameuel is from. She represents the best of India and the best of humanity. God bless Sandra Samuel and little Moshe and the souls of all those who lost their lives in the Mumbai terrorist attacks.

maya   December 5th, 2008 352 GMT

what a wonderful story of love and sacrafice. maybe if those pakistani terrorists had someone to love and hold them when they were little, they would not have turned into such merciless killers.

SAM   December 5th, 2008 513 GMT

All I Can Say That I’m Crying Right Now Its Too Much Already To Hear About This Tragedy It Just Breaks My Heart

Ashok   December 5th, 2008 635 GMT

I am a Father of two children and I know how much Moshe could have been comforted if he had his parents alive. Thanks be to God for sending Sandra and her loving heart towards Moshe, also risking her life to protect the little one. Thanks you so much. I wish every human will be brave like you.

Shilpa   December 5th, 2008 645 GMT

Baby Moshe broke all of India’s heart. I hope one day he will return to India to see what it took from him, to reconcile the horror that took his parents away from him and to also know the country that loves him. He is also of India’s as much as of Israel.

sakthi   December 5th, 2008 658 GMT

You are great!

B Khan   December 5th, 2008 718 GMT

Heart breaking story …

I am reminded of an episode of Mahatma Gandhi. During the horrifying riots while India was being partitioned, a Muslim man came weeping to Gandhi saying his wife and son had been killed by a Hindu mob and in a fit of rage and revenge he had gone and killed a Hindu family. Now he was so repentant at what he had done that he wanted to kill himself. Gandhi instead told him to adopt a Hindu boy orphaned by the riots, and raise him like his son, but while making sure that the boy is brought up in Hindu customs and religious beliefs. The man did just that and found peace.

I wish Moshe could be adopted by a Palestinian couple who might have lost their child to Israeli action. I am sure there are several such couples in Gaza and elsewhere in the region. If an Israeli boy is raised by a Palestinian couple, and the boy is raised as a practicing Jew, this could become a showcase of basic human unity. I realise I am being too idealistic, and so called “pragmatic” people on either side will not be enthused by the idea … but what the heck, if we shun ideals then what are we left with?

Any human, whichever religion he might follow, and whatever angst he/she may carry towards “other” religious beliefs, cannot be human if he does not see his/her own child in Moshe’s eyes.

To Moshe: God does what He does for a reason only He knows about. Keep your faith in God. May God bless you.

miriam   December 5th, 2008 721 GMT

Thank you Sandra and thank you Paula for bringing us her story.

James Boblan   December 5th, 2008 729 GMT

that is a very sad story

Lhaine, Philippines   December 5th, 2008 735 GMT

i am a mother of a 1 year and 4 months old boy. i admired sandra of what she did. Thank you sandra and God bless you!

Rabbeca P, Spring Valley NY   December 5th, 2008 749 GMT

I’m a mother of a couple of children including my 18month old baby….

Any normal good person after being shot at and hiding for 12 hrs, would have RUN out of deaths path without turning back. But our hero Sandra was completely selfless and risked her life to save a little boy. …Not her child… Not a family member… Not sharing religion… All that mattered was she can save the Baby! A human being!

God bless Sandra and Moshe.

Shikur S.   December 5th, 2008 750 GMT

Feeling very sad to look at the sweet face of Moshe. How can somebody kill innocent people? The real perpetrators of this heinous crime are not the 20 to 25 year old (kids) who carried out these attacks in Mumbai, but those located in safe havens in Pakistan who brain-washed them to such an extent that they forgot the preciousness of their life and others. To this day, they are being protected by the powerful and allowed to continue spill their vicious poison and hatred with anti-india , anti-west speeches and slogans. Free world “go after this monstrous snakes” even if their government play double games.

Marinda   December 5th, 2008 800 GMT

Wow. Inspiring indeed. It sometimes kills me to imagine that the human race I am a part of is capable of this.. but it is not something we have become, to a certain degree this is the animal in us that comes out to maim and kill. Worse than animals, we have the intelligence to cause much greater destruction.

Chamanthi   December 5th, 2008 805 GMT

This is a really touching story .my loving baby…You are so lucky to have a such caring person like Sandra.God bless you!

david   December 5th, 2008 805 GMT

Dear Sandra,

with a heart full of tears a beg the lord, our god, that you may merite in heaven the best god gives and may you merite the garden of eden.

I cry and cry when I see this photo. What a hero you are. We salute you.

Fritz   December 5th, 2008 809 GMT

An angel saved a little angel. Thanks you God for giving us brave angels like Sandra. God bless Sandra

Dr. Leonard, Bangkok   December 5th, 2008 812 GMT

I commend you Sandra.. and pray that this child will grow up in love and not in violence. He will be in good hands now.. and safe from the terrible people who have no conscience..

As a father of 3 young daugters too I am totally saddened by the incidents inflicted on the poeple of Mumbai… and my prayers go to the families of Moshe and Sandra too..
God Bless you both…

thank you Paula to highlight this…to the world.

T   December 5th, 2008 817 GMT

Hunt down the group where ever they might be hiding and all of their supporters and annihilate them.

Clint, US military   December 5th, 2008 819 GMT

Sandra is the very definition of hero and self-sacrifice. Her actions speak to her character and quality. If all people acted as she, our world would be a much better place to live. I sincerely hope that her devotion the child and his family is lifted up for all to see and I hope that she never changes for the attention she will receive. I would consider it a true honor to meet her and shake her hand. I pray God will pour His greatest blessings on her.

Lilllian   December 5th, 2008 832 GMT

Very touching story indeed. Thank you Sandra for displaying extra ordianry courage. God still works through humans. God bless you.

ike emodi   December 5th, 2008 833 GMT

Sandra deserves an award for bravery or I recommend her for a nobel award,such rare acts of heroism and kindness shouldn’t go uncelebrated in this era of celebrating junkie celebrities

Venkat   December 5th, 2008 837 GMT

I pray that Moshe grows up to be a strong boy who will do a lot of good in the world. I am right now in India and it was heart-rending to watch the TV when Moshe was crying incosolably. Tears come to my eyes when I think how Moshe has to cope up with knowledge that his parents were so brutally and inhumanely killed by the terrorists. Shame on the human race that we have such terrorists living in our world.

I don’t think thanking Sandra is appropriate. We just need to admire her devotion for the little boy and pratice it in whatever way possible in our own lives.

Abuomer   December 5th, 2008 837 GMT

Iam a muslim and my heart breaks for Moshe . Those who made him orphan are nothing but criminals in all senses. My best wishes for the cute little boy Moshe and GOD bless him and punish those terrorists.

Bireswar   December 5th, 2008 839 GMT

I am the father of a 16 months old boy. Every time I have read about Moshe over this past week; tears well up in my eyes thinking about what he would have seen and undergone during those terrible hours. I really fail to understand how can anyone even think of hurting a 2 yr old child.
I wish and pray with all my heart for Moshe’s well-being and happiness. Sandra, as a fellow-Indian I am proud of you and what you have done. God bless you !!

Kumar   December 5th, 2008 841 GMT

Thank you Sandra.

You are a true hero filled with love amd compassion. For Moshe you are the mother now and hope that you take care of him untill he becomes independant.

This is what democracy in India stands for. You have made all free and democratic nations proud.

You are indeed an example of bravery unseen in many years.

Shukri   December 5th, 2008 842 GMT

She’s a mensch. She was one of the few rays of hope from that those dark days. I still struggle to accept that in this day and age, innocent Jewish civilians who openly embraced other culture and the world could have been targeted this way just because they were Jewish. This has to be stopped.

RS, Manila, Philippines   December 5th, 2008 852 GMT

Reading from the accounts of what transpired during the attack by the gunmen in Mumbai, I cannot fully comprehend how the cause of jihad by those apparently Islamic militants was furthered by the deliberate physical assault on the little boy Moshe as shown by the very clear handprint on his back.

Rajan   December 5th, 2008 852 GMT

For a little kid to lose his / her mother at such a tender age and keep yearning and crying for them, not knowing they are dead is the ultimate cruelty.

The reason for this is again GWB who made Pakistan an ally in the war against terror, knowing full well that the ISI run by pakistan Army (of which Musharaff was the leader)!

The world continues to pay for the blunder US has made by keeping Pakistan its ally. US should help in eliminating Pakistan’s military capability – if it can punish Iraq for not having a WMD – it can punish Pakistan whose terror base laid the foundation for 9/11.

Biju Varghese   December 5th, 2008 855 GMT

“Inner Strength & Devotion” aptly said of you Sandra
Thank You a brave face of Humanity

Indian   December 5th, 2008 856 GMT

Thanks for getting this heart touching news. I broke out in tears while redaing this…….

Dasari,Auckland   December 5th, 2008 857 GMT

As God saved Moses ( Ex.2),Moshe was saved from bullets. I wept after reading Moshe story.I am really wondered at Sandras dareness and timely wisdom. May God Bless Moshe and Sandra.

Emeka Abakporo   December 5th, 2008 858 GMT

i must say a big thank you to Sandra for that act of kindness. For Sandra and those that will be around to tell “God Saved” Moshe all that happened to his parents, should’t fail to tell him everything that happened.

Jas   December 5th, 2008 858 GMT

Sandra you such a loving and caring person.The world needs more people like you..May you be blessed with abundance… Our love to you and Moshe..

Mmoley   December 5th, 2008 859 GMT

I have a 4 year old and it is every mother’s wish that her child or children have a Sandra in their life. Sandra and Moshe’s bond and story is one bright spark in what has become a very dark world.

Neha Modi   December 5th, 2008 901 GMT

Being an indian, I am really proud of sandra. She has shown unbelievable wisdom and courage during terror. Our prayers with Moshe forever.

Neha Modi   December 5th, 2008 903 GMT

Being an indian, I am really proud of sandra. She has shown unbelievable wisdom and courage during terror. Our prayers with Moshe forever.

sihle rambakupetwa   December 5th, 2008 903 GMT

Thank God for people like Sandra, may the good Lord bless her and family. She does deserve an award of some sort.

aya   December 5th, 2008 905 GMT

i am a mother of two. and the thought of people bringing harm to my children is more than i can bear. thank God for people like sandra who braved all odds just so to save the life of one precious child.

Loizos   December 5th, 2008 907 GMT

Sandra and little Moshe’s story is the epitomy of human endurance and vistory over evil. My thoughs and prayers will be with them always. I am certain almighty god has a special destiny for them.

Selvarajah   December 5th, 2008 907 GMT

My daughter is 2 yrs. I understand how upset Moshe is when he can’t find his parents around him. It is heartbreaking to read the story which I have done at least 10 times in different sties. Every time I read, I tear without realising. Thank you Sandra and please stay with Moshe as long as you can. If I ever have a chance to visit Israel, I will visit you. God bless you.

Loizos   December 5th, 2008 909 GMT

Their story is the triumph of good over evil. My thoughs and prayers will be with them always. I am certain Almighty God has a special destiny for them. May they live in harmony and propserity

anuj   December 5th, 2008 913 GMT

thank you sandra so much. May god bless you with good health ,hapiness and strength to look after moshe. Lots of love to moshe.

tina, denmark   December 5th, 2008 920 GMT

Sandra, you are a real living angel. Your bravery and love is applauded.

lalitha khanna   December 5th, 2008 921 GMT

It is so natural for a normal human being to want to comfort a child. But I’m afraid these natural impulses are stifled in our urbanscapes. Wonderful for Moshe he had sandra but I wish some of these people who walloped the baby could see this story over and over and over in a confined room. I am no psychologist maybe they won’t react but just maybe some vestige of humanity surfaces and they see what they have done.

Abdulqadir Abdulhameed   December 5th, 2008 921 GMT

I am a Muslim and disgusted with the terrible incident in Mumbai. Muslims, Jews,Christians, Hindus whatever our faith is! our believe should be in humanity. I cry for the little boy and i hope when he grows up we will be able to muster some courage and have some answers to what happened to his parents.And for the Nanny i say with people like you hope is still alive!

Jyotsna Gandhe   December 5th, 2008 923 GMT

One would normally be deeply scared under these conditions. It shows inner strength for someone to not worry about themselves and take care of the small boy. Hats off to Sandra

saurabh prakash   December 5th, 2008 929 GMT

it is good to applaud sandra. what she did was truly heroic. however, what about the manager of the taj hotel who, despite the fact that his wife and children were trapped (and later died) on the 6th floor, listened to his mother’s advice and helped rescue other hotel guests. he lost his entire family. how in the midst of all that was happening to him he was able to help others i hope i am some day able to understand. his story is truly herioc and tragic. i salute him and his mother and i pray for his wife and children as also for the others who perished in this nightmare.

vallesca   December 5th, 2008 935 GMT

As i read this letter it made me really sad.
i feel that who ever is responsible for the attacks in Mumbai needs to think of what they did to this kid and even other kids because they had destroyed a very special part of kids lifes and you know what that is well it is family that love you every one around us loves us.
so the people need to get a life and think of what they did to other peoples lifes.
Vallesca,
Student of the Canadian International school Singapore
I hope people think of what they do before they do something
Sandra did a every special thing to this kids life.

k c shum   December 5th, 2008 935 GMT

Sandra has shown the fundemental humane behaviour that every worthy human being has. The islamic terrorists should re-think the teaching of their religion.

norbert, philippines   December 5th, 2008 950 GMT

This brings to light the need for us to give special importance for nannies who are as deeply involved as we are in taking care of our children. It is sad that we only remember them when things like this happen but tend to forget them in our everyday dealings with them. They are a very special group of people and a part of our families. They deserve our love and respect.

Thank you Sandra. You will always be remembered for your wonderful deed.

Bhawna   December 5th, 2008 950 GMT

She has done a herioc act! May God bless her.
I have a three years old son, being a mother I am heartbroken that this innocent life would not be able to get love and care of his parents. Little Morshe may god bless you and you have a great life ahead.

Oliver   December 5th, 2008 1007 GMT

Sandra’s acts of heroism transcend colour of skin, language and religion.

This is the way we should co-habit with our brothers and sisters, no matter where we come from. When I think of Sandra I see wings and a halo. She is Moshe’s guardian angel and an example for everyone to follow.

There’s almost nothing good to come out of these sickening events in Mumbai, but one thing stands apart, head and shoulders above all else.

Sandra’s heroism proves that mankind has not become a monstrosity. Sandra’s unwavering will shows the sheer determination, courage and inner strength that we are all capable of. I do not know Moshe, but I thank Sandra for setting a precedent and an example. Her acts of heroism were not acts of violence or revenge, but through sheer love for her own brothers and sisters, she defied the odds, risked her own life and ensured that Moshe will live to see tomorrow.

It brings tears to my eyes to see people taking the lives of others, in a world where violence has become protocol, Sandra’s actions tell a story a thousand words cannot begin to introduce.

I do not belive in god, for god would not allow mankind to destroy one another in such cold blood, but whatever is out there, watch over Sandra and Moshe. Robbing a child of his parents is one of the singular most despicable and evil acts that man is capable of.

I dont not wish this fate on anyone, but maybe these monsters should hear of this story…

To Sandra, the Guardian Angel. You inspire me. I cannot find more words to describe my sentiments.

I wish Sandra and baby Moshe all the best, as often you have to lose something to gain something else. Moshe has Sandra and Sandra has Moshe. Testimony enough that her selfless acts will at least always be remembered by Moshe at least. Even when the public has long forgotten this story.

Sandra, I won’t forget you…

Madhuri Sheth   December 5th, 2008 1009 GMT

Sandra,

I salute your bravery and inner courage. You have displayed such exemplary behaviour that I have no words to thank you. As a mother of a 5 year old I feel terrible everytime I see the baby’s face on TV on internet. It is just heart breaking that someone can do this horrible act and orphan an inncocent sweet child. May there be more like you Sandra.

As an Indian in UK I feel dissapointed that we have not taken any action so far and hope that maybe Israel will do something.

Regards

Keshava   December 5th, 2008 1039 GMT

Dear Sandra, I salute your courage and dedication. You have not just saved one child, but in my opinion, in that one act, you have demonstrated everything that is so beautiful about being a human being and an Indian.

Lola   December 5th, 2008 1048 GMT

It is heartbreaking to read of this little boy and I keep replaying in my mind the site of him crying inconsolably for his mother at this parents’ funeral. I have a 10month baby and this is very real to me.

I pray that in spite of this tragedy litlle Moshe grows up to be a great man who will be a blessing to society, the rest of his family and the memory of his parents.

I laud the action of Sandra and pray that God rewards her a hundred-fold for what she has done.

Uday, Mumbai   December 5th, 2008 1052 GMT

I salute Sandra for her devotion to Moshe and of course for her extraordinary courage. Thanks Paula for bringing us this heartwarming (although heartbreaking at the same time) story with so much sensitivity.

OCGODSON   December 5th, 2008 1054 GMT

SANDRA, YOU ARE MY 2008 HEROINE OF THE YEAR. GOD BLESS YOU.YOU SHALL NEVER, EVER LACK.

Sunil   December 5th, 2008 1125 GMT

I salute the dedication of Sandra. God Bless Moshe and Sandra and pray and hope that Moshe will come through all of this. I think that both Israel and India should work together to track down the leaders of the terrorist organization and eradicate them. Israel has the expertise to help the Indian government.

Dipangshu Ray   December 5th, 2008 1127 GMT

Sandra did a great job. I can not control my tears for little Moshe. It’s a heart breaking event. God, keep Moshe always happy. I want to request Sandra plz stay with him.

HB   December 5th, 2008 1138 GMT

Dear Sandra,
Thank you so much for showing us what we just about have forgotten – the humanity God put in us. Thank you for being an example of humility and kindness towards others. Wall Street could learn much from you.

My heart goes out to all the victims in Mumbai.

Tessie Farrugia   December 5th, 2008 1148 GMT

Well done Sandra. GOD BLESS YOU and MOSHE.

K K   December 5th, 2008 1149 GMT

I am sick and tired of this news story..

While some acts of terror committed by a handful of individuals are indeed reprehensible, yet hundreds of thousands of Arabs and Muslims have been killed or tortured by the US and Israel over the past few years and we have yet to see such extensive, in-depth, repetitive coverage concerning those atrocities relative to this news story!

Over the past few days, Israeli settlers have burnt Palestinian homes in Hebron and expelled their inhabitants at gunpoint..Heart-wrenching scenes of Palestinian mothers carrying their babies and looking for food and shelter have not made their way to the CNN..The people of Gaza have been exposed to a horrendous siege that denied them of their basic needs and exposed to one of the worst forms of collective punishment known to mankind just because they exercised their democratic right to vote!

Unfortunately, the slow, painful, tragic death of entire Arab or Muslim communities or the plight of hundreds of thousands of Arab or Muslim orphans under occupation seems irrelevant to CNN..

Simcha Dov, Israel   December 5th, 2008 1151 GMT

Sandra has earned her her being cherished by the entire Jewish nation through her act of selflessness and bravery. I was present at the funeral for Rabbi Gavi and Rivky Holzberg, Moishe’s parents, and such a heartrending site is difficult to comprehend.
Sandra, you truly are a hero, not just for Moishe, his late parents and his family but rather for the Indian and Jewish nation as a whole. After those days of terror you help restore one’s faith in humanity.
Thank you

Umesh kumar Chhabra   December 5th, 2008 1156 GMT

Dear Sandra

Sandra is pure Human being compareable to the God. Islamic terriorst should learn something from her to end hatered and live in harmony .

Abdulkadri   December 5th, 2008 1156 GMT

An Indian saving a Jewish Baby, I tell you that a good muslim woman will also do the same. If we all remove bitterness in our hearts irrespective of our beliefs the world will be a better place.
As a Muslim I am proud of the Sandra and anyone who value life.

Raj   December 5th, 2008 1158 GMT

The ones who are responsible will pay the price sooner or later.. He is not a orphan anymore everyone will cherish him as their own kid.

Raj   December 5th, 2008 1207 GMT

long live Moshe

M.Houston   December 5th, 2008 1209 GMT

It:’s people like Sandra that will finally bring peace to this world.

Aza   December 5th, 2008 1209 GMT

That is a sad story, May world become safer and free of terrorists for Moshe for Sandra and also for rest of the world.
God bless you Sandra and Moshe

Sree   December 5th, 2008 1210 GMT

I am afraid that I cant read on any more…..my eyes are watering and my lips are trembling……so much of sorrow for all the world…I am afraid that I might be caught crying….

L.   December 5th, 2008 1217 GMT

Love conquers all. It conquers fear, anger, injustice, segregation. If anyone asks where can we find miracles these days? Love is the miracle we can still see everyday.

paul   December 5th, 2008 1223 GMT

A movement to enable all people the freedom to convert to another religion without being threatened by the state or religious police should be made and wriiten in to the charter of united nations. An entire people in many countries are unable to free themselves from their shackles in the absence of this freedom. What is human rights all about without this basic freedom that people in western and democartic countries have and enjoy.

zohar freiberg, israel   December 5th, 2008 1229 GMT

Dear Sandra,
I decided to write a letter to members of the Knesset, the Israeli Parliament.
I think the State of Israel should find a way to help you for saving Moshe’s life.
God bless you!

Jean de Belen, Philippines   December 5th, 2008 1240 GMT

Sandra,I have been touched by your courage (not to mention your presence of mind) to get the child amidst all those terrifying gunshots to save him and yourself as well. Don’t let that guilt eat you because you just did the best thing which could have been done out of those fatal circumstances. You have a good heart.

Bobby   December 5th, 2008 1302 GMT

India loves you Moshe….And our Nation salutes u Sandra.

Billy   December 5th, 2008 1307 GMT

I feel terrible looking at Moshe. Looking at him makes me sad because he did not deserve this. A two-year-old saw his parents, whose deeds are nothing but a testimony of what love is, has to bear life without the love of his parents. God bless Moshe ! I hope I can meet him one day.

Clem Douglas   December 5th, 2008 1309 GMT

This nanny has shown the highest level of godliness possible, self-sacrifice to save another human being. I am deeply moved by her heroic deed.

kanji hirani western australia   December 5th, 2008 1406 GMT

Dear
sandra
ithink israeli mamber of parliment
should find a mosh beter living in rest of her nany lief
god give more power to sandra

Mohammad Asghar   December 5th, 2008 1410 GMT

God sent an angel to earth and named her sandra samuel to save little moshe. What a brave woman. i salute her .

mohammad asghar
jeddah
saudi arabia

dr.avinash manwatkar.   December 5th, 2008 1416 GMT

when i have read this story my eyes filled with tears.i do not know the tears are of joy or sorrow. and i have read this story about the boy at least thrice.i read every thing about Moshe on this CNN website.
when ever i see this boy’s story my heart fills with emotions and my eyes become heavy with tears.
what this you call.
,God has given us joy that Moshe is alive and sorrow that he is orphaned.
but he is not alone,his nanny is there and so are people around the world who read and see their story.God is really great.

Gholamhosain Tasbihi   December 5th, 2008 1426 GMT

I am extremely sorry for whatever has happened to the parents of this child and others. I am fed up with all kinds of violences. I think the roots of these kinds of violences are in Israel, USA, Gaza, Afghanistan, Somalia,Pakistan and Iraq. The Policy and Government Administrators of the countries such as Israel, USA and other western countries should be based on honesty and justice towards the people of other nations. They should think that all of us are humane and love our traditions, ideas, religiouns, parents and lands where we live. Israel and USA Administrators should tell their nations that all people all over the world are the same: good and nice to live with them peacefully

Zo   December 5th, 2008 1442 GMT

It is a really touching story, and I read it with a sense of wonder, that this Moses too has been rescued by a woman belonging to another people.

It touched me esp. to hear the story that the rabbi at the funeral said to the baby that he would have no father or mother to hug or kiss him…….

I hope baby Moshe grows up strong and healthy, a boy his parents would have been proud of, and that his nanny Sandra is always there for him to love and support him the times he is scared or lonely.

God bless you both and stand by you Sandra and baby Moshe.

Steven   December 5th, 2008 1450 GMT

Great story, but let’s be clear on one point. This child’s parents did not “perish” as if by some unexplicable cause. They were targeted, tortured and exectuted by Jihadist terrorists simply because they were Jewish. The rabbi’s wife was also 6 months pregnant, a fact that for some reason is rarely reported. Make no mistake, if given the opportunity these Jihadists would not hesitate to slaughter ever one of us as infidels.

Wisdom   December 5th, 2008 1501 GMT

Its time that Mossad joined hands with India and take complete control on the terror outfits. Israel should shed out its traditional conservative outfit and start fighting terrorism from other lands…Such a lovely boy orphaned, ah !!! the blood of every Indian boils against these heartless Jihadis…

God bless Moshe and his nanny for such a courageous act….

Ejike Anigbogu, Nigeria   December 5th, 2008 1505 GMT

Any further proof of Guardian Angel? You need not go far. I have just seen one in Sandra. In the midst of turmoil, a quiet center exists devoid of terror induced pains. That quiet center is well etched on the peaceful faces of Moshe and her guardian angel. God that saved him will see him through!

Sara   December 5th, 2008 1509 GMT

Sandra,

You are a bright light in a dark world. May G-d bless you for eternity.

LR   December 5th, 2008 1511 GMT

oh what a lovely boy,
Tears cannot dry,
Hearts will cry,
Memories run high…

Moshe, Shalom to you from all the Indians from India….

Liz   December 5th, 2008 1514 GMT

Thank you Sandra for your amazing act of heroism. You enlightened the world by showing a motherly love to little Moshe. I hope this is a message to all mom’s in the world. Being a mom myself I think all moms can influence our kids to be good citizens of the world. If we take the responsibilities to introduce good deed to the minds of the generation we produce these terrorists will not be there anymore.

Kenneth ,Bacelona   December 5th, 2008 1520 GMT

Sandra,just tears from my eyes about this story.you are one in a million,God will always give you the strenght and wisdom to take good care of Moshe.

Njenga   December 5th, 2008 1521 GMT

woo! i cant help but i got tears in ma eyes…its a moving story….

Njenga   December 5th, 2008 1523 GMT

woo! this story is too moving…i got tears in ma eyes…

pauloh   December 5th, 2008 1533 GMT

May God bless Moshe and Sandra for her courage.

Ayuba Marafa   December 5th, 2008 1607 GMT

This is a very sad, moshe will be feeling the demised of his parent spiritually even though he does’nt know the event that took place, sandra has done a wonderful job, God will pay you abundantly & bless moshe to be a wonderful humanbeing in terms of good doing. For the terrorists took this evil act God will never forgive you.
For the world crises that is rampaging, middle east crises is the source of all the suicide, extremism and other related evil doing. Pls let there be peace and justice in the middle east so that the world can be relieved. I’ am sending my condolence to all the families that lost their love ones in the mumbai tragedy.

A. K.   December 6th, 2008 903 GMT

Sandra, we won’t forget you. I ( born in India) and my friends feel so sorry for the baby. It was a touching moment watching TV. We all pray to God for Moshe. Our request to Israel’s Government to make Moshe’s life comfortable. It would tragedy to send him to a Orphan house. Sandra and Moshe are both great. One day I wish meet Moshe and Sandra.

victoria cooper   December 8th, 2008 1315 GMT

to the man who think that a palestinian should raise a jewish child in
his jewish faith is beyon belief……

i can only say he should get a life

no one but a jew can raise a jewish child PERIOD

This story is still hugging my heart and soul and to read foolishness is
beyond contempt.

surya   December 8th, 2008 1316 GMT

yes this is great story and yes, sandra is a hero, but what about the REST of her story? Here and in all the other news stories she is defined solely in terms of her having saved Moshe. She mentions that she has two children of her own: where are they? How old are they? Were they also allowed to accompany her to Israel? What happened to the person that was hiding with her in the storeroom? A wonderful as the story above is, it is terribly incomplete.

Dennis   December 9th, 2008 429 GMT

i think that we should help that the kids affected in the attacks; will be able to have a secure future…

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CNNInTheField on TwitterGet In The Field updates when they appear online via the Web, SMS, or instant messages.

Follow CNNInTheField

From our Partners
Categories
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. All comments should be relevant to the topic and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. You are solely responsible for your own comments, the consequences of posting those comments, and the consequences of any reliance by you on the comments of others. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying and other information you provide via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  Asia  |  Europe  |  U.S.  |  World  |  World Business  |  Technology  |  Entertainment  |  World Sport  |  Travel
Podcasts  |  Blogs  |  CNN Mobile  |  RSS Feeds  |  Email Alerts  |  CNN Radio  |  Site Map
CNN en Espaňol  |  Arabic  |  Japanese  |  Korean  |  Turkish
CNN U.S.  |  CNN TV  |  CNN International  |  HLN  |  Transcripts
© 2009 Cable News Network. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by WordPress.com VIP