Comments on: Stakes high in Pakistan's battle against Taliban

By: Majid Khan (Lahore - Pakistan)

Majid Khan (Lahore - Pakistan) — Mon, 08 Sep 2008 08:45:48 +0000

Rasmi
i dont know where u live...........Pakistan or abroad (or even if u r a paksitani)............n have any idea about the culture & life about the people living in northern areas of Pakistan...........but let me tell u one thing, the only way to bring peace in this region is a TWO step process:

1) US forces (or NATO).....one the same thing...........should leave the area unconditionally IMMEDIATELY

2) Pakistan & Afghanistan Governments should involve local population to bring peace in the region as it was a practice centuries ago

The policy of "enforced peace" using American Gun wont help the issue..............Pashtoons live in this area n they will live here for good, so let them handle the issue by themselves with "backdoor" diplomatic help by the respective Governments of Pakistan & Afghanistan backed by, although not desired, US.

Any other solution will bring more instability, deaths of innocents and more rage against US, Pakistan & Afghnaistan Governments.

By: Marnie Tunay

Marnie Tunay — Sun, 07 Sep 2008 18:52:21 +0000

Thanks for this update, Nic, I found it informative. I hope to hear more from you on this issue, which I am following closely. I really appreciate your succinct writing style, as, like most readers, I am short on time; but I want to stay informed. I have book-marked your blog.
Marnie Tunay
http://fakirscanada.googlepages.com/
http://fakirscanada.spaces.live.com/?lc=1033

By: Ramsi Hashash

Ramsi Hashash — Sun, 07 Sep 2008 12:19:16 +0000

Raja,
To a certain extend I understand you and also agree with you, but one thing we Muslims and I would like to include the Arabs (which are multi religious).
It is time that we stop blaming other and do our own things. Get our nations straightened out. Tradition, culture and religion are not a problem in modern society. So what does it take to get 80% of the Islamic/Arabic world out of the past and into the future?
Who cares whose soldiers or freedom fighters are better than the other one? It will get us no where?
You want to beat the West specifically the countries you mentioned? Go ahead and help educate your fellow brothers and sister, lead them to the future which obviously should and must include our heritage, and religion. We need to look forward no backwards. God never asked us to stay on the level where we are and put our head in the sand. He wants us to excel, to improve without forgetting him.

Education, economy etc should be our weapons, but are we really so different than those who we blame for our situation?

By: M Khan

M Khan — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 15:39:17 +0000

America is using any excuse they can to hurt muslims they don't care how many they kill, childern and woman doesn't matter and rest of the world is blind folded.
America don't and can not diffentiate between taliban and local citizen and the war is getting very unpopular in the region and will not get local support at all incoming days. "killing of inacent civilians " is like taget practice for US and allied forces in Pak-Afghan border. Soon allied will have to with draw or start another propoganda to stay in course. "No free hand to kill any one US forces it must end" American people are mislead and war is doing good to the 1 community only.
American must wake up not to let take advantage of their blood and money. Say no before too late.

By: Raja

Raja — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 11:21:02 +0000

1 thing which annoys me most about americans,Israelis,Britishers etc(muslim blood thirsty nations) is that they sit on computer whole day writing insane comments against Islam and Islamic countries.They openely suggest the ways to kill innocent people in the name of war on terror.Well they have tried all their ways but Islam is spreading at lightening speed.Good thing is west is getting humilating defeat in Iraq and Afghanistan despite all the military technology they have.All they can do is to kill innocent people with UMV machines and aerial strikes.They cant and will never face freedom gighters in open feild.I wish Iraqis and Afghanis get freedom from american terrorism soon.Do not spill human blood in the name of war on terror.Let humanity live.

By: NS

NS — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 09:05:25 +0000

Zardaristan is a far more dangerous place to live in than even Talibanistan. In a world hungry for oil our geography has doomed us and now to make matters worse we have thieves as leaders. Our nation is up for sale and we can do nothing but watch. Watch as we our told that every location that is necessary for the US to secure as a base for its connectivity to Central Asia and the oil in the Middle East is the breeding ground for Al Qaeda?!! We are on the road to nowhere and people like Zardari are only going to make the journey longer and more painful than ever. God bless Pakistan.

By: Ramsi Hashash

Ramsi Hashash — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 02:41:58 +0000

Majid,
Let us talk about Pakistan, how will Pakistan in the future deal with their provinces at the Afghan border? Let us forget about the US etc. Obviously those regions are run more by the tribal culture than through goverment authorities. Lahore and Karachi are not Waziristan so how if at all would you suggest the goverment of Pakistan to approach bringing the future in to this remote regions?
I for myself believe that time is the only real solution, but the question is does Pakistan have the time?

By: Ramsi Hashash

Ramsi Hashash — Sat, 06 Sep 2008 01:52:25 +0000

Majid,
I suggest nothing else than what the US did before the send ground troops to Afghanistan. I was not suggesting to do this on the Pakistani side, but suggesting that after the carpet bombings which did happen, the US should have sent their 150000 troops to Afghanistan not Iraq. At the same time specail forces could have cut of the escape passes into Pakistan.

Jami, nobody suggests that any miliatry intervention would have gotten ride of the Taliban, but they certainly would have had a better chance to get the top leaders of Al Qaeda and the Taliban if they would have done it in this way.

The result as it stands no, is that the US has made more enemys in Afghanistand and Pakistan and that will hurt them in the long run.

Jami, of course there where no WMDs in Iraq that was clear long before the US invaded. But right now we are talking about the troubles in the Afghan / Pakistan region.

I am also fully aware that the Taliban are a sold part of some regions in Pakistan, so obviously you will never be able to get rid of them.

By: Jami

Jami — Fri, 05 Sep 2008 11:55:03 +0000

Those who thinks for a malitary solution to end Taliban lives in a fools paradise. It is their land and their home ground and one day those fighting here have to go back.
Lets us be honest , the fight is for capturing world resources. In Iraq there were no terrorists and no WMD but still the world was mislead.
If we want to save this world we have to adhere to honesty of our conscience and not the propaganda with wicked intentions behind.

By: Majid Khan (Lahore - Pakistan)

Majid Khan (Lahore - Pakistan) — Fri, 05 Sep 2008 09:15:32 +0000

Ramsi, r u out of ur mind?................sugguesting a full scale carpet bombing on a very large mountaineous area comprising a large papulataion, do u have any idea how many innocents would die if this happens.............insane idea from an insane person to an insane & cruel Nation