Edition: U.S. | Arabic | Set Pref
May 7, 2008
Posted: 1013 GMT

MOUNT EVEREST PRESS CENTER, Tibet Autonomous Region, China — After an eventful week, with all that travel at high altitude and hectic but futile efforts to find out what is happening on Everest, I finally felt tired.

Between cans of Red Bull and cups of instant coffee, I did a few live shots for CNN International on Friday morning and in the afternoon I agreed to visit a 1,300-year-old Rongbu De Hermitage Monastery during a three-hour organized tour by the officials from Beijing Olympic Committee.

The monastery is built on a small flat area in a slope about a hundred feet above the bottom of the valley.

It took me 15 minutes to hike up that little hill with my camera.  I was exhausted and regretted going. Once on the top though, the exhaustion melted away.

There was an immense sense of spirituality at this place and I was almost afraid to take pictures. I sat on a sun-heated stone listening to the sound of prayer flags madly flickering in the wind and finally gathered the courage and energy to film.

The weekend was miserable. When I stumbled out of our hut on Saturday morning I discovered to my horror and disbelief that fresh snow was falling.  The magnificent view of Everest disappeared behind a frightening wall of dark gray clouds. I didn’t want to imagine what it was like on the mountain.

I was busy with live shots and with trying to keep myself warm, which isn’t easy here since there is no heating around. I just put on as many clothes as I could and kept drinking hot water.

My problems were nothing compared to two other journalists from our group. A cameraman got a serious and extremely painful tooth infection and after an agonizing night (”It’s been years since I cried”) was put on painkillers and strong antibiotics. 

My room-mate was struggling with high blood pressure and low blood oxygen levels causing debilitating fatigue.

The cameraman since recovered, but our German colleague was evacuated back to Beijing. The rest of the group was holding on, struggling with ever-present cold and increasingly with boredom. There is not much to do — apart from waiting for the weather to improve.

On Saturday evening, Everest cleared for a few minutes. The giant has changed dramatically since we last saw him 24 hours ago.  Even in the orange light of setting sun one could see the fresh snow cover blanketing almost the entire mountain.

However beautiful, it creates serious problems for the climbers. Walking and climbing in deep, fresh snow is exhausting at high altitude.  Even more serious, fresh snow causes dangerous avalanches. Records show that Himalayan avalanches killed hundreds in a century of climbing here.

There is even more snow on the ground on Sunday morning. 

Expedition spokesman Zhang Zhijian shyly admitted during the regular morning press conference that the climbing on the mountain had stalled due to bad weather. He had no information about the weather forecast for future days. 

Although it became sunny in the afternoon, Everest remained hidden behind clouds and in the evening, the snowfall returned back to the valley and began covering the Media Center again. The temperature was dropping not only outside. Long faces of the trip organizers and of some of the journalists during Sunday dinner spoke volumes about the weather concerns.

One person who remained optimistic was a Chinese experienced climber and an official adviser to the expedition, Liu Jia. “I would not even consider it a storm,” he told me that day in a filmed interview. “I do not think it will affect the climbing activity too much and for too long.” he added. 

After filming we chatted a little bit longer when he said: “According to my experience, if there is a lot of snow, there will be a big break after and it can create good opportunity to climb to the top.”

The next day we woke up to a gorgeous, bright sunny morning. 

Posted by: ,
Filed under: China • General • Olympics


Share this on:
S.K. Cheung   May 7th, 2008 2315 GMT

Glad to hear you’re hanging in there. Hope the weather cooperates soon. In the meantime, good luck and good health.

Daria   May 8th, 2008 244 GMT

Wow, good job! It’s all worth it in the end. It’s like the matrix revolutions at the end when they see the sun, hehe.

Sophia Keller   May 8th, 2008 248 GMT

It is highly unlikely that the Olympic torch has summited Everest. All details of the climb have been concealed from the media, typical of Beijing controlled events. And the sudden announcement of an easy summiting without any opportunity for independent journalists to observe or check facts, is also typical of Beijing’s manipulation of information. It’s probable, and quite characteristic of PRC’s history, that the footage “proving” the summitting was simply shot at base camp.

Xeanni   May 8th, 2008 248 GMT

Free Hawaii from USA, Return the land to Hawaiian
USA out of Hawaii.
Shame USA….Shame USA

We would support Hawaiian until they independent.

Peter   May 8th, 2008 407 GMT

The Chinese Olympic team has successfully reached the top of Mt Everest. Congratulations. Well done. All the efforts to thwart saboteurs have paid off.

Superbug   May 8th, 2008 455 GMT

Well done and this deserves more reporting than this. Keep it up. Go Olympic!!!

S.K Cheung   May 8th, 2008 551 GMT

Just read the story about the flame reaching the summit. Good video link on the CNN home page as well. Congratulations to all the climbers.

Andy Young   May 8th, 2008 556 GMT

well done, that moment was so moving and touching!

Allen   May 8th, 2008 717 GMT

What a great chapter being added to the Olympic History! Congratulations to the climbers! Salute to all field journalists!

Adam   May 8th, 2008 1051 GMT

i have just seen the torch reahced to the top of the mountain, but only showed in cctv, i wonder if i should believe it or not, since it quite often lies. Well done, Tomas, i can imagine how tough it is.
with regard!

jing   May 8th, 2008 1331 GMT

thanks to all the climbers,they did a great job!!!!!!!

Danielle   May 8th, 2008 1408 GMT

I think Sophia brings up a good point. Although I would like to believe they reached the summit, this is the ONLY picture I have seen atop of Everest that doesn’t have a blue sky above the clouds. It makes me wonder…

William Liu   May 8th, 2008 1415 GMT

What an exciting moment! Go China Go!
Thanks for the blog!

CkMok   May 8th, 2008 1416 GMT

the Olympics run up to Everest Is a great feat achieved in terms of endurance and spirit … well done !! and NOW all the way to Beijing !

… ignore and let it pass, the unhappy stories that arise from the politicising of sports lately and let this coming Olympics be yet another great and exciting one for the world to rejoice !

James   May 8th, 2008 1516 GMT

It is so cool. Cong!!!!

ashley   May 8th, 2008 1518 GMT

a disgraceful show of colonial power. Tibet is not part of China and this arrogance will backfire.

Helena   May 8th, 2008 1531 GMT

Amazing efforts! First time ever. Very inspiring. Huge thanks to everyone up there. Come home safe.
Peace to the world,

Adma   May 8th, 2008 1538 GMT

Adam’s comment reminded me that many people in the world now believe NASA made up the manned moon landing in a secret studio.

LORENZO TAN   May 8th, 2008 1607 GMT

China is on top of the world !

Jane   May 8th, 2008 1641 GMT

Hi Tomas,
Thanks for your hardwork. I’ve read about you from Sohu’s interview. Hope you can read it, but it is in Chinese. http://2008.sohu.com/20080505/n256668763_3.shtml

I will translate a few words for you.
Tomas as a person - ‘a very good journalist, a very kind man.’ by Lizhi Li.
You and your colleauges– hardworking, very professional, pay attention to detail, and very sensitive to new information. Timing of asking questions.

They said you are from Czech Republic, a climber yourself, was praying for the event.

Hope you find this a fair report about you and your colleagues.

howard   May 8th, 2008 1729 GMT

Go Olympics. What a great job done by the climbers. This is a historical moment.

angie   May 8th, 2008 1842 GMT

hi, Sophia Keller, which era are you from and how many languages do you understand? How can you be faithful to news stories , which I believe , all in English , by western media?

I believe you have been branwashed , much more than me. Its true , that , the Chinese media dont always report things as fast as the western media. However after many years of observation, I have found that the westren media are so free , as to as tell lies and make up stories of their own .

Chen   May 8th, 2008 1957 GMT

Congratulations to Tomas for surviving the cold and high altitude. At least you got to see the beauty of Mt. Everest. Have a safe trip back down.

Good job for the Climbers, Tibetans and Chinese alike. You are brothers. So don’t fight.

Orsino   May 8th, 2008 2252 GMT

well done

FUNG   May 9th, 2008 126 GMT

We were at the base camp four years ago and living in the new temple hostel for a night. The Mt. Everest was always in the cloud even though the sun shone with blue sky until 10 p.m.
The climbers had done a fascinating job for all Chinese because one might have to wait many days before they had a glimpse of the Mt. Everest.
Go! Go! China. Let us all enjoy the Olympic Games.

Jenny   May 9th, 2008 135 GMT

congratulations to China! it’s not about Chinese media or western media. Media is sort of the same thing.no matter what, just don’t be so easily skeptical about those miracles achieved by others rather than you…or else,everyone is Einstein

Adam   May 9th, 2008 955 GMT

To all those who support China,
I implore you to have some empathy and compassion to other people, especially for Tibetans, 99 percent of them are suffering under Communist rule since 1950s and all of them want Dalai Lama back to home to be their leader, bring peace and happiness and get rid nuclear station. Please, all of you should face the reality, the true History. You all know that Tibet was invaded by Maoist by force, brought more than 1.2 million death merely in 1959. and you all know that Tibetans and Chinese are totally different in many ways, the way of thinking, the way of believing. They are peace loving people, not like Chinese elits too egocentric. Don’t lie to others and most importantly to yourself just for self-defence, which is totally arbitrary. Those people including Tibetans themselves who support Tibet independence is not because they hate Chinese people, but the way the Communist regime treat them is inhuman.
Thanks for your love and compassion

grace   May 9th, 2008 1108 GMT

To Adam:
inhuman??
why did we build schools, hospitals and railways in Tibet?
we developed and look after that place, and u call it inhuman.
have u ever been to that place?
and by the way, dont just only emphases “china invaded …. 57 years ago”
our history is more than two thousand years, not only 57 years.
before 57 years, Tibet was still a part of China. Even, Dalai said he was not after independence.

grace   May 9th, 2008 1121 GMT

To Adam again:
“egocentric”
any western people who have ever worked with Chinese should know that we are not “egocentric”, selfish, or aggressive.
we didn’t invade Iraq.
we didn’t make money from exporting opium to other countries.
we didn’t massacre.
we were invaded by UK, France, Spain, Portugal, America, Germaney, Japan and so other western countries for more than a centure.
you were and still are colonial power, not us.
so Adam, u stop lying

Jian   May 9th, 2008 1154 GMT

Adam,

Please study history of Tibet first, especially the history before 1950.

To me, American Indians are very different to American white, both in language and culture. I do not know how many are killed, but I know not many in percentage survived afterward. How about thanksgiving day?

Ho   May 9th, 2008 1533 GMT

Don’t you feel ashamed to call it Mount Everest. The montian is in Tibet, it has the name in Tibetan, check it out.
The western are full of arrogance; they entered other people’s backyard and they assumed they were entitled to put their own name of the backyard.
Shame on you
Please give respect to the other culture!!!!
Be civilized!!!!!

EnlightenYou   May 9th, 2008 1547 GMT

Adam:

You need a lot of education on this topic and I’m going to add a few more points:

1. Go find a map, any map, that’s published in the past 100 years by any country (inlcuding your own). You’ll find XiZhang (Tibet) is WITHIN the border of China without exception. So a country invaded itself? Maybe Webster has another definition for the word “invade” that I’m not aware of.

2. The new Chinese government (”Communist” in your word) replaced the previous Chinese government (the one in Taiwan now) in Xizhang in 1950. Dalai Lama started the armed revolt in 1959 with direct financial and military support from CIA (yes your CIA) because the vested interest of his and all the slave owners was challenged by the Communist government. they represented 5% of the Zang Chinese (Tibetan as you call them). It shouldn’t be a surprise that most of the other 95%, who were slaves, welcomed the change. Without the grassroots support, Dalai Lama and CIA failed miserably and fled.

So what you ended up with is that most of the 100,000+ Tibetans in Exile are former slave owners and their decendents, whose vested interests were taken away by the Chinese government. Oh yeah they were pisted off, wouldn’t you. As to the other 95% of Zang Chinese (Tibetans) in XiZang? Their population has since doubled. I’m not saying they live in heaven. Nobody does. However, most of these people’s lives are NOT what you think to say the least.

Most of the numbers that I cited above can be found easily on the web. You can go to the CIA website to find declassified documents on its accounts on happened in the 50s also.

I’m from the province where Shangri-La is located (it’s not in the XiZang Autonomous Region, mind you). It’s truly beautiful place. I hope you have the financial means and human curiosity to visit the region someday. It’d be an exhilarating experience, as Tom attested in his blog. Not to mention spending your money there helps the locals far more than your lip service.

angie   May 9th, 2008 1557 GMT

Adam;

You are too dumb, you dont know what you are talking about. Its not a fault to be ignorant, but its your fault to be here misleading people by spreading your message. If you know Chinese, then go to some websites, see the detailed videos of the climbing , you will be amazed , that many of the climbers are Tibetans, They are so proud to be Chinese . Just 3 of the 5 torch bearers of the climbers are Tibetans. Ask them if they want Dalie Lama back or not ?

Cindy Law   May 9th, 2008 1604 GMT

To Adam, please give any proof that “99 percent of them are suffering under Communist rule since 1950s and all of them want Dalai Lama back to home”. Did you do a head count or you just enjoy cooking up rumors. No one can deny the significant improvement in Tibet unlesss he just simply chooses to be deaf and blind. Better send you to Tibet before 1950s through a time machine so you can enjoy being a serf/slave as 95% of the Tibetan people.

Tibetan   May 9th, 2008 1942 GMT

From a legal standpoint, Tibet has to this day not lost its statehood. It is an independent state under illegal occupation. Neither China’s military invasion nor the continuing occupation has transferred the sovereignty of Tibet to China. As pointed out earlier, the Chinese government has never claimed to have acquired sovereignty over Tibet by conquest. Indeed, China recognizes that the use or threat of force (outside the exceptional circumstances provided for in the UN Charter), the imposition of an unequal treaty or the continued illegal occupation of a country can never grant an invader legal title to territory. Its claims are based solely on the alleged subjection of Tibet to a few of China’s strongest foreign rulers in the thirteenth and eighteenth centuries. If other countries were to make such tenuous claims based on their imperial past, how seriously would they be taken? Are we not, in even considering the merits of China’s arguments, accepting the right of powerful modern rulers to invade foreign countries in order to recreate lost empires of their ancestors?

Michael C. van Walt is an international legal scholar and a board member of the International Campaign for Tibet. Reprinted from the Cultural Survival Quarterly. Vol.12 1988 Number 1

S.K Cheung   May 9th, 2008 2004 GMT

To Angie: I’m not sure you can conclude someone is “dumb” just because they disagree with you. If you “fault” others for spreading a message, you can similarly be faulted for doing exactly the same. I’m sure not all Tibetans are unhappy, but I’m also not sure how the opinion of 3 torch bearers can represent Tibetan sentiment as a whole.

syama   May 9th, 2008 2319 GMT

To Angie and all Tibetan Sovereignty misguider’s

How many of you have met exiled Dali Lama? Most likely none of you who hates even the idea of Tibetan sovereignty even bothered to know him if not in person, then at least by reading materials available also! Because all of you are so brain washed by your communist government that you can not think beyond your so called tunnel vision!!!!!

I admire and respect Chinese intelligence (I mean intelligent students from China all over the world ) so with due respect, t it is something like that you guys can get 2380 in GRE but can not speak two lines of straight English !!! Why because you can memorize very well the things told by your teachers or government but can not think beyond written lines. What I mean that since it is told to that Tibetan can not govern themselves(same way as Britishers said that Indian can not govern themselves, but see what happened??) so you can not think beyond that!!! Isn’t it right ?????

But my friends, to survive in the 21st century all of must change our tunnel vision and start seeing in a broader perspective, as world is a common place in this century.

Also, some of you talked about Tibetan slavery….but occupying another’s land is considers what do you guys know???? It is your pleasure/problem that you are 1.3 billion big/strong but that does not mean that you will so that power in occupying another’s land where ever possible!!!!

Shame on government of the Republic of China’s rotten policy and those who believe it!!!!!

syama   May 9th, 2008 2328 GMT

To Angie and all Tibetan Sovereignty misguider’s

How many of you have met exiled Dali Lama? Most likely none of you who hates even the idea of Tibetan sovereignty even bothered to know him. If not in person, then at least try to know him by reading materials available also! And because all of you are so brain washed by your communist government that you can not even think beyond your so called tunnel vision!!!!!

I admire and respect Chinese intelligence (I mean intelligent students from China all over the world ) so with all due respect, it it is something like that, that you guys can get 2380 in GRE but can not speak two lines of straight English !!! Why because you can memorize very well the things told by your teachers or government, but can not think beyond written lines. What I mean to say, that since it is told to all of you that Tibetan can not govern themselves, so you can not think beyond that!!! Isn’t it right ?????

But my friends, to survive in the 21st century, all of us must change our tunnel vision and start seeing in a broader perspective, as world is a common place in this century.

Also, some of you talked about Tibetan slavery….but isn’t occupying another’s land is considered similar in this time and age???? It is your pleasure/problem that you are 1.3 billion big/strong but that does not mean that you will so that power in occupying another’s land where ever possible!!!!

Shame on government of the Republic of China’s rotten policy and those who believe it!!!!!

khan   May 10th, 2008 202 GMT

Syama,
Please go to Tibet or China if you really want to make a difference.
Do you really think people in Iraq can decide who will be the next president in Nov?

Khan

kevin   May 10th, 2008 217 GMT

Jesus… so much effort for nothing. Taking a torch 8,000 meters high. A tremendous effort, lots of money spent and all this buzz for nothing! Amazing the ability of this humankind to dedicate the attention to useless things like this…

Chen   May 10th, 2008 314 GMT

Hi ?????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We all agree, Chinese or Tibetans alike, Dalai Lama is so great that he deserves to rule a larger piece of land. So forget about that small place called Tibet. We voted to have him to come to rule US and EU combined. Are you happy now? Go ask the US President, UK PM, EU President to resign and make room for him. Because Dalai Lama likes to combine religion and politics together too. I would throw in the Vetican too so the Pope needs to be gone to make room for him.

S.K Cheung   May 10th, 2008 339 GMT

To Chen: that’s funny. A PRC citizen voting I mean. What did you get to vote for, exactly? Since China currently rules Tibet, and you’re offering the Dalai a governing role, perhaps let the Dalai rule China, and that way he’ll rule Tibet too. Or perhaps you can stop trying to be facetious, because your attempt fails miserably.

Tsering   May 10th, 2008 504 GMT

Haha…there is nothing great about it. Provocation is the worst someone can do. Shame on you Chinese. You have eaten our country, our people and now you are eating our Holy Mountain.. I wish you all the worst in live. Free Tibet.

drishya gurung   May 10th, 2008 523 GMT

hey great job,it’s really nice to hear you are continuously fighting with the climate but any way i am sure u’ll overcome it and complete ur expedition with full energy.all the bst

Tibetan   May 10th, 2008 729 GMT

A worker from Tianjin said, “[The regime] is truly sparing no costs. I am sure they won’t even make much money from the Games. We common people want food, housing, and to survive, not the Olympic Games. What’s the significance of the Games? We have worked all our lives and only make a few hundred dollars a month from our pensions. Inflation is steep, and I have a whole family to feed. How can we survive? Some people say supporting the Olympic Games is showing patriotism. What do we have to show, for our patriotism?”

A person from Shenzhen remarked, “Inflation, unemployment, and stock market losses are all serious. The burden of debt is so heavy. What can the Olympic Games bring to the common people? Isn’t it just a torch? The torch relay has no meaning, and is a pure waste of money and time.”

The person went on, saying, “The government is too vain. They really don’t spend money wisely. If they used the money on health insurance, more Chinese people will be able to see a doctor, and fewer would have to die, while their family members must watch helplessly. The government will have to pay for its vanity, at some point.”

A migrant worker from Anhui Province commented, “It has to be a world record that the Olympic Games has brought in troops from four different military regions. The government can’t even take care of daily things, let alone defend the Olympics. There are so many thieves and robbers in the streets. How many of the crimes are ever solved? I myself was robbed today. I felt helpless and totally unsafe.”

A person from Beijing said, “I think the Beijing Olympics will incur a financial loss. The expense of using the military, public security officers, police, as well as all levels of public or private guards, will add up to a huge sum. The whole population has been involved in defending the Olympic Games, as though a civil war was about to break out. Is the Olympic Games a sports event or a war? Why are TV and radio trying to spread propaganda about ‘waging well this defensive battle for the Olympics’? I think the Chinese government is treating everything as its enemy. They are not providing security. They are initiating a war.”

Tomaso Zugara   May 10th, 2008 1459 GMT

Whomever said the Chinese are not self centered and xenophobic has not spent any time in China. You can be killed crossing the street simply because a driver is to selfish to yield to a person in a crosswalk. The Chinese people are so brainswashed by the propoganda from their government many of them believe the nononsense published by “The People’s Daily” Yes, there are netizens from China who can circumvent the country’s firewall to reach western news sources but their minds are so shackled\condidtioned by the years of government propogaanda.they have lost the ability to objectively analyze or critique world events.

The Olymplcs is all about “Face” for the Chinese and it has nothing to do with promoting social harmony. Manyof the posts of this blog are from Chinese zealots “defending” their country’s honor and congratulating the Olympic flame team from supposedly climbing Mt. Everest which so far has been the ultimate PR farce as hundreds of Tibetan monks are sstill confined to their monasteries. Th truth is most Chinese know nothing about Buddhism which is the ultimate irony because it was spread from China thorughout Asia including Tibet, Japan, Korea etc.. Offering joss sticks at a temple and praying for good fortune is not Buddhism LOL

The govenrment and the Chinese people demonize the Dali Lama because most know nothing about the man or the religion he represents outside the lies they have been told by their government. The Chinese people would be wise learn tfrom the Dali Lama instead of listenining to all the lies from their government. Socilialism is a doomed economic system and democracy one day will rule China. Only then will the Chinese people be free.

Chen   May 10th, 2008 1529 GMT

To S.K.Cheung,

Can you tell I am kidding? You need some funny bones, man!

There is a problem with your logic. We, Chinese, don’t think Dalai is good for China so no China or no Tibet for him to rule. The West thinks he is great and we, Chinese, agree that Dalai can rule the West.

Adam   May 10th, 2008 1617 GMT

To grace and those who wrote to me,
Yes, China has opened many schools in Tbet to brain wash Tibetan people with communist propaganda, abolishing their invaluable culture and language and religion. Yes, China built railway to Tibet to loot thier minerals and bringing in millions of chinese people to make Tibetan people minority in their own land. Yes, China built hospitals for their own people in TIbet. hi I studied in China and Tibet for 10 years. I know how most Tibetan people and many ordinary Chinese people felt about the inhuman communist regime, its inequality. i read history about the reason of Chinese occupation in Tibet both inside China and outside. At the least i know what is made up stories and what is authentic. Most westerners including me who support Tibetan people for a complete autonomy is not because we are paid to do so and Tibetan people have no money to give but their precious culture, religion and peaceful way of life to give us a good example, that life is not to be slave to worldly material things but happiness, inner happiness and i respect that. All their wealth has been taken away by the Chinese. We are doing this because we have human heart. Yes, it is wrong that American and British have invaded iran and Afghanistan, they are at the least not trying to eradicate their precious culture and language and religion, and they are not taking their land away like Chinese are doing to Tibet, but I agree they are there for minerals. Hi, brothers or sisters, we don’t have to argue who is wrong or right and you can’t judge yourself but others, but we have right to have our voice heard in western countries, this is not in China. Angie said, I am dump, it is may be right, but that is his or her judgment not everybody’s but her or his words will also be judged by others not by himself.
Cheers lads
because they deserve it and we have

Ryan   May 10th, 2008 1619 GMT

History is often distorted. Sure the Chinese culture has a lot of history, but so does Tibet. These are two completely different cultures. I hesitate to say that I’m American. I’m truly a world citizen. Every culture should have the freedom to maintain their values independent of foreign controls. Tibet should be independent and so should any other culture who “feels” oppressed by another. I would not argue whether they have been oppressed or not, the fact is, they want to be independent. I’m proudly non-ethno-centric. If the Puerto Rico, Guam, Samoa or Hawaii want to be independent that is also within their right since they have their own cultural heritage. Peace and freedom to all cultures!

S.K. Cheung   May 10th, 2008 1701 GMT

To Chen: yes, I knew you were “trying” to be funny; I was merely pointing out that you weren’t that successful.

li lue   May 10th, 2008 2157 GMT

To Adam,
Thanks for your supports for FREE TIBET,i really appreciate your words and i feel pity for those chinese who put point finger at His Holiness Dalai Lama and dont understand the true history of TIBET.
You had given the right answer to them.
Keep it up…
FREE TIBET

Chang   May 10th, 2008 2248 GMT

First they littered their junk in space and now they have dumped all that mountaineering garbage atop Mt. Everest - All for the glory of China. Here is a news flash China, China will never be glorious in the minds of the rest of the world until it acts like a grown up, and not as an arrogant, violent, bully and a selfish show off. China has always been arrogant and authoritarian and is still socially and politically backward, perhaps it is too much to expect the Chinese nation to understand this elementary fact.

Florence   May 11th, 2008 855 GMT

to syama: Yes, you are right. Chinese students know little about him and Chinese students are good at memorizing. However, have you ever met people from Tibetan? Do you have Tibetan friends? How many Chinese students do you know? If you have access to China’s Central Television, please watch the National English Competition at the end of the year. I bet the contestants can speak more than three English sentences…By the way, are you sure what you read is true? My opinion: nothing is true unless you believe it.

tenzin nyandak   May 11th, 2008 1603 GMT

Torch relay through Mt. Everest is just an act of claiming Tibet as part of China… Tibetans are not at all happy under Chinese rule as proved by uprising in all over Tibet recently.

So there is an urgent need for a ‘meaningful, long term and transparent dialogue’ between His His The Dalai Lama and Mr. Hu Jintao. This is the only solution to achive peace and harmony for Tibetans as well as Chinese.

Chinese   May 12th, 2008 501 GMT

To SK Cheung,

Yes. Before I go. I will like to congratulate you being turn your skin white and remain a happy second class citizen staying in the west.

Please wait for another 30 years and see how CCP will build China and the Asia as a whole. See how CCP going to made Asian proud and live with dignity include your mother land Korea.

S.K Cheung   May 12th, 2008 508 GMT

To Chinese: yes, please now go hither into the night. Good riddance. Your foolishness knows no bounds.

Chinese   May 12th, 2008 618 GMT

To Sk Cheung,

Why get so angry? Your Korea also invested a lot in CCP China. Ask them to pull out from China. The Korean are perpetuating the rule of CCP in China.

Hypocrite.

Chinese   May 12th, 2008 739 GMT

To Syamma,

Yes. I read many books written by Dalai Lama. But I do not see that he acts like what he written.

Tibetan buddhism is no difference from any buddhism. We all follow the teachings of Budha.

A true buddhist do not involve in politics and also religious issues. The buddhist even build Mosques in Iran. Iran people appreciated by not killing the goat as a sacrifice when the Mosques are completed.

Dalai Lama should call upon the West to pull out from Iraq and Alfaganistan. The longer they stay, more people will dies.

Ask them to spend the wars money to save many lives in this world especially human lives. The money they spent in the wars can at least feed 1 billion people for their entire lives.

Do not just concentrate on a Tibet issue. Nobody dies of hunger in Tibet. But during his time in Tibet, many farmers slaves died of hunger.

There is no cultural genocide. Tibetan buddhism or buddhism as a whole are strongly propogated by CCP. Go to china and ask any Lamas or Monks.

Dalai Lama should be teaching Buddhism and not Tibet problem.
If he is a ture buddhist, he should know what is “Karma” and what is the “common Karma”.

By the way, do you know Gautama Buddha’s own country was destroyed? What Budha said is only this “This is karma”.

Bhodisava’s job is to help every human beings or at least make them survive and not empty talk like telling the poor man “Hey, you know the bread taste tastier if you go with butter” . How can the poor man knows when he even cannot afford to have the bread?

Dalai Lama job is to encourage these poor people to survive and give them some comforts. Use his influence to lessen the anger, hatred and infliction caused by those heartless people.

Dalai Lama should not just go around the western wolrd sto talk about Tibets. As a Nobel prize winner, he must at least speaks for the people suffer under the wars. Everyday people are dying. He must
at least tell the west “hey, let do some good Karma, stop the wars and let the common karma of the people work, what ever leaders they have chosen, they will pay for it. It is their common karma.”
Tell the west today if they keep on killing they will pay for their own karma. It is better to stop now.

What I understand from Buddism is compassion. Compassion has no country and no religion. Buddhism is not a religion. We have no superior God to reward us or punish us. We responsible for our own Karma. Even Buddha had to paid for his karma in this world.

Chinese   May 12th, 2008 948 GMT

To Syama,

Oh, I forget. Even Pope condemned Bush for the Iraq war. What about Dalai Lama? Is his exiled government still financed by the CIA? Does he took any money form the Wests or his worshippers?

Budhha’s teaching: A monk should not touch money. A monk should just have enough to cloth himself and take no more than a meal per day. Does Dalai Lama practices this? But I saw a beuatifull watch on his wriste?

Is Dalai Lama has the time to practice “pariyatti”, “patipatti” and “pativeda”? Does he achieved “sammadithi”?

If the answer is no, then to me he is just a buddhist scholar or a person who study budhism .

Please check all the Dalai Lama before this Dalai Lama? Does any previous Dalai Lama involved in politics like he does. Does any previous Dalai Lama joint forces with the west to upset China.

Does any previous Dalai Lama instigate his people to kill for what ever cause whether right or wrong? If this Dalai Lama does not instigate, he should chase the youth wing out of his camp. Do not let them become ” the worms inside the Lion Body” and destroy buddhism. Always remember buddhists do not KILL. Buddhist prefer
death than creating a bad karma.

( To those who do not understand the phrase” worms in Lion Body”- the meaning is those guys disguise as budhists and in actual facts are doing something harmfull to buddhism, just like the worm inside the Lion body)

Buddhist do not fear death . Born and reborn is normal to us. But we fear bad karma. Please do not instigate another killings.

To true buddhist , even if you have the right cause, you still cannot kill.
Killing will create hatred and the hatred will be carry to and by their childrens. One day these children grow up they will hate the Tibetan. Just like the palestinian children, they will hate the Israel.

“Buddham Saranam Gacchami” - May Buddha bless Dalai Lama

Adam   May 12th, 2008 1241 GMT

To the Chinese,
One of my Chinese friends in my university has written a dissertation on bilingualism in China and the communist’s government’s treatment to minority people. I found it extremely interesting. But unfortunately he said he could not take his dissertation with him to China. He said he could even be arrested for shot for what he has written. Here are some paragraphs I have excerpted from his dissertation for you to read and see what you think about it. If you want to read more about his dissertation, he permit me to let you to read. Cheers.

Bilingual education which the Chinese communist government began to provide for the minorities in China has been closely connected with the governement’s political policies. Lin says that since 1980, bilingual education has been provided in most minority schools in order to build up a relationship with ethnic minorities in China. However those schools which were trying to apply bilingual teaching have been continually bombarded with problems. The biggest problems noticeably came grew from inside society to a large extent, where minorities even now, in the 21st century, face discrimination and bias. (Lin, 1996: 45)

Lin points out that at the worse period, from 1949 to the early 1980s, assimilation was enforced on the minority students to conform. Their uniqueness had never been recognised . Autonomy and local initiatives were out of question, instead conformity to the centralised control of the Communist government were demanded. At the time minority cultural customs were hugely denounced as backward and subjected to attack. It was compulsory that all minority schools use Mandarin, the Han language. All the schools were forced to teach a curriculum which was designed for the whole nation regardless of local levels of economic development and culture. Minority teachers and students had but little choice but to take up the standard curriculum and mode of teaching. (Lin, 1996: 50)

For example, in Tibet Tibetan children are treated differently from Chinese pupils. Tibetan pupils were discriminated against inside their own country. The Chinese education system requires Tibetan students to learn Chinese, the Han language as their first language, leaving Tibetans with little education in their own language. The resettling of the Chinese people in Tibet has left Tibetans as a minority in their own country. Catriona Bass states that education of Chinese children in Tibet is far superior to that available to Tibetans. The Tibetan language and culture are treated as inferior. The Tibetan language is hardly taught in secondary schools. There is therefore little choice of employment left for those Tibetan students unless they speak fluent Chinese. (Catriona ,1998: 131)

Willian points out that the curriculum, laid down by the Ministry of Education in Tibet, which is directly governed by the communist government polices, included Tibetan language as merely a foundation subject which has no use after primary school education. (Willian, 2000: 187)

Gladney says that in China all schools have to follow the centralised curriculum which is designed by the State Education Commission. Students from minority regions also have to use the same set of textbooks and are expected to progress at the same pace as all other Han students. The subject areas are fixed, leaving little flexibility to local schools. Parents and local governments have a very limited say over what should be taught and how teaching is to take place. Within this context, bilingual education is provided only for the purpose of teaching the national curriculum so that they can master it as effectively as the majority students do. It is seldom a concern that knowledge about the minorities themselves is not being incorporated into the curriculum. (Gladney, 1994: 60)

Xinyu points out that the curricula are too difficult for the minority students and it hardly meets any of the local educational needs. For example, Chinese language textbooks are mostly filled with Han classic canons. Not only have the minority students never had any previous contact with these, but they are also remote from their lives and the language they use daily. Often they have to go through dual translation to understand the content. And yet, at the end of their study, minority students have to compete with the Han students on an equal basis for admission to colleges and universities. As a result, the proportion of minority students in every kind of major post-secondary and higher education institution has always been much lower than that of Han students.(Xinyu, 1995: 32-3 )

However Xinyu says that scholars in China have firmly claimed that providing bilingual education for minority students, especially for cognitive reasons, is indispensable for the development of their intellectual ability. They argued that students who are not able to learn in their own language miss the crucial stage in their life for developing an interest in learning. They argued that especially for those minority students, who come from remote areas and who barely had any contact with the Han culture and any other languages apart from their own native language, being taught in their own language is absolutely invaluable.

S.K Cheung   May 12th, 2008 1719 GMT

To Chinese: still here I see. What happened to going back to the asylum? It’s not too late, you know. A man of his word, how honourable.

syama   May 12th, 2008 1837 GMT

To all Dalai Lama haters,

How can you hate someone without even knowing him?????? I know and can contrubute a lot about Buddhaism, however, I prefer not to discuss it with those who are, brainwashed, contradicting themselvs, have tunnel vision, and so insecure that have no understanding of right or wrong!!!!!!!!

So on the name of humanity please have compassion for the world peace! Every bit of positive deeds would lead us towards brighter and better world.

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.

Previous article:
Panda politics

subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.

Categories
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. Please note that CNN makes reasonable efforts to review all comments prior to posting and CNN may edit comments for clarity or to keep out questionable or off-topic material. All comments should be relevant to the post and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying information via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  Asia  |  Europe  |  U.S.  |  World  |  World Business  |  Technology  |  Entertainment  |  World Sport  |  Travel
Podcasts  |  Blogs  |  RSS Feeds  |  Email Alerts  |  CNN Radio  |  CNNAvantGo  |  Site Map
© 2008 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by WordPress.com